Oliver Twist: Depicting Crime and Poverty

Oliver Twist: Depicting Crime and Poverty


So here we have a passage from the original
manuscript of Oliver Twist and this is just the moment when Oliver suddenly is trapped
into criminality, so he’s being led into this world by Fagin and the Artful Dodger,
he goes out for a walk with them and suddenly the Artful Dodger starts pick pocketing. He
runs away and poor Oliver is left to take the rap, and Dickens says the police officer
arrives, who’s always the last person to arrive in such cases, so he’s already making
that sharp, satirical edge to it. And then you see the suffering of Oliver, the indifference
of the law to him, and then at the end of it, ‘Don’t hurt him,’ said the old man
compassionately. So the victim of the crime who turns out to help Oliver is on Oliver’s
side. But the law and the police are brutally indifferent to his pain.
So crime is at the centre of Oliver Twist and there is a group of novels in the period
called Newgate fiction and in some ways Oliver Twist is like Newgate fiction, in other ways
different. Newgate fiction is often accused of glamorising crime, of making it look too
exciting, as if these figures who can transgress against the norms of respectable society are
somehow morally admirable. And Dickens is fascinated by that and the possibility that
there might be a kind of life outside respectable, bourgeois life, but at the same time also
he wants to give a moral purpose to it. So there’s constantly a war within Oliver
Twist about a side that wants to be fascinated and entranced by what crime can do and the
freedom it allows one, on the other hand the wish to give a moral purpose or design to
it. And you also see Dickens who is clearly at this point, you know, he’s a young man,
he’s experimenting with different kinds of fiction. Within the novel itself he describes
what it is that he’s trying to do. Melodrama, he says, alternates comic and tragic scenes
like the red and white in the side of a streaky bacon. And that’s what he wants to do too,
so he’ll often move from very comical moments to very tragic or dangerous or threatening
moments. And Dickens wants to say not just that melodrama does that and that he does
that, but also that’s a form of realism ‘cause he says that’s what life is like.
We do that in our own lives, we might move from a scene of merriment to a funeral almost
instantaneously and he says just as we do that in life so too the novel must reflect
that. So Oliver Twist is a great success and we
know it’s read throughout society, there are popular representations and theatrical
adaptations that the poor watch, but it’s also read by Queen Victoria for example who
says she finds it excessively interesting. And there’s an interesting exchange between
her and Lord Melbourne who’s the Prime Minister and he doesn’t want to read Oliver Twist,
he says, ‘It’s set amongst workhouses and pickpockets and coffin makers and people
of that sort. I don’t wish to know about them in reality and I don’t wish to read
about them in fiction.’ So there you see two very different aesthetic responses to
Oliver Twist, one that wants to see it merely as a representation of an unpleasant reality
and therefore shouldn’t be seen, and then the much more engaging response and engaged
and intelligent response of Victoria who says she finds it excessively interesting. So Dickens is a deeply theatrical writer and in the later half of his career he has a very,
very successful career as a public reader And what he does is he carves out of his novels
these moving, humorous scenes and episodes. And the most famous of these is Sikes and
Nancy, which is the moment in Oliver Twist when Sikes, the criminal, bludgeons to death
Nancy, the prostitute. Now they’ve always been controversial, his readings. His friend
John Forster told him that he shouldn’t do it, that it was the exchange of a higher
calling for a lower and particularly he was opposed to the Sikes and Nancy reading because
of its violence, because of its sexuality, because of its effect on the audience. So
he knew that he could hold an audience absolutely in the palm of his hand with his readings
but above all with the Sikes and Nancy reading and you know, would peak himself on the number
of women who’d been carried out fainting from the auditorium.
So this is Dickens’s own reading copy of Sikes and Nancy, so the death of Nancy from
Oliver Twist, and it’s full of his own markings. So you can see him here adding little bits,
more exclamation marks, and then action here, so he’d be acting it out, and then
alerting himself to the murder, so the death of Nancy is coming, murder coming, he writes. So here
he is building to the climax, action again, unlocking the door, giving us an extra pause,
up to three exclamation marks now. All the key words underlined, key phrases, just thinking
through everything as a performance, as an enactment of these horrific, terrifying emotions. Just before Oliver Twist comes out the new Poor Law is passed, and this is the most revolutionary change in the lives of people at the bottom of society that’s ever been seen. And so
Oliver Twist begins in a workhouse and there’s a constant campaigning radical social anger
in the book against the stripping of dignity of poor people. And you see that both in the
novel and also in Dickens’s personal life and in the campaigning journalism that he
writes at the same time. So Oliver Twist has some of the qualities
of a parable or an allegory or a moral fable, but it’s also got a documentary side to
it, and Dickens is very keen to demonstrate that he’s based in a realistic description
of criminal London, and he gets very angry when Sir Peter Laurie complains that this
is a novel that’s unrealistic in its depiction of the world of criminal life.
And in the preface to the cheap edition he takes on his critics in the most explicit
way possible. He writes at page 267 of the present edition of Oliver Twist, there is
a description of, quote, ‘the filthiest, the strangest, the most extraordinary of the
many localities that are hidden in London, and the name of this place is Jacob’s Island.
11 or 12 years have elapsed since the description was first published. I was as well convinced
then as I am now that nothing effectual can be done for the elevation of the poor in England
until their dwelling places are made decent and wholesome.